Login  Register

Re: Analyzer, perimeter and filling (was Re: magic wand)

Posted by BenTupper on Jun 12, 2009; 3:27pm
URL: http://imagej.273.s1.nabble.com/magic-wand-tp3692147p3692156.html

On Jun 12, 2009, at 11:16 AM, Wayne Rasband wrote:

>> A heartfelt thanks to Michael for Versatile Wand - very nice!  But  
>> it has me thinking which invariably leads to confusion!
>>
>> I want to make sure that I have things straight in my head  
>> regarding the functionality of (a) the built-in Wand functionality,  
>> (b) the built-in FloodFill, and (c) "Analyze particles..." .   And  
>> then I have a question.  First some statements...
>>
>> (1) Wand currently only performs 8-connected searches,
>
> The built in wand tool in v1.43a will be based on Versatile Wand, so  
> it will have an option to perform 4-connected outlining.
>
>> (2) FloodFill uses 4- or 8- connected which the user selects by  
>> double-clicking the bucket icon,
>
> That is correct.
>
>> (3) "Analyze particles..."  (as Analyzer, or is it  
>> ParticleAnalyzer? or PolygonFiller?) uses FloodFill and Wand but  
>> flood filling is only 8-connected.
>
> The particle analyzer is currently only 8-connected but it will be  
> easy to add a 4-connected option once the Wand class is updated to  
> support 4-connected outlining.
>
>> Playing with this test image (http://www.tidewater.net/~pemaquid/test.tif 
>> ) I think this last statement is always true, but I would like to  
>> get confirmation from others.
>>
>> My question is how can I make "Analyze particles..."  optionally  
>> work in a 4-connected manner.  Does it require a major  
>> reconfiguration or simple tinkering?
>
> It will require simple tinkering, or perhaps only checking "4-
> Connected" in a dialog, in ImageJ 1.43.
>


YeeeeeeHaaaaaa!   That is wonderful!  Thanks!


Ben Tupper